I run KANJIN, a digital stamp card for small shops: cafes, salons, barbers, bakeries, food carts. Before we release a big update, we test it the hard way. We give it to new testers who play real owners, and we ask them to do eight everyday jobs without help.
This week I gave two other stamp card apps the same eight jobs: StampMe and FaveCard. Both are good products with real customers. I wanted to know one thing: if you are a busy owner, how much of your week can you actually get done in each one?
The eight jobs
These are the jobs our testers do every round. They come from what owners tell us they need, not from our feature list.
- Start: set up your card and reward, and get to your main screen.
- First customer: find the QR poster for your counter, and give a walk-in customer their first stamp.
- Reward: a regular's card is full. Check it and give the reward.
- Message your regulars: tell them about new holiday hours.
- Automatic message: have the app bring regulars back on a slow, rainy day without you doing anything.
- Results: find how many customers came back after a message.
- Money: enter yesterday's sales and see if you are breaking even this month.
- Supplier bill: record a bill due next Friday and see what you still owe.
For each job, we check three things: can you finish it alone, do you hit a dead end, and how many extra steps does it take?
How I tested (so you can judge it)
- English screens, the owner's website on a desktop, 17 November 2026.
- Both rivals were on their free trial. Because I used empty test accounts, I could not fully test giving rewards or sending messages in their apps. For those jobs, I only judged the path up to that point.
- I did not install their phone apps or create customer accounts. Some jobs live in those apps, so I could not test them.
- I make a competing product. I tried to be fair, and I asked Google's Gemini to judge the same notes independently. It was stricter on both apps than I was.
What I found
Setting up was fine everywhere
All three get you to a working card. StampMe walks you through four steps and asks for terms and conditions. Its template fills in brackets like "[X days]" that you then rewrite by hand, which slowed me down. FaveCard's card editor is clean, with five clear tabs, though pages often took several seconds to load.
Stamping a walk-in customer is where they split
This is the job that matters most at a busy counter.
- StampMe asks customers to register and then nudges them to download the Stamp Me app. To add a customer yourself, you fill in first name, last name, email and phone.
- FaveCard puts the card in the customer's Apple or Google Wallet, and staff stamp it with FaveCard's merchant phone app. I only tested on a desktop, so I did not see this in action.
- KANJIN lets you type the customer's phone number on the screen at the counter and press one button. No app for the customer, and none for you.
Messaging your regulars: FaveCard's screen is the one to beat
FaveCard's "Write your own" campaign is one page. You type a short note, it shows a preview of the phone lock screen, and the Send button is ready right away. It also has good starting templates: Slow Day, Win Them Back, Happy Hour. This is better than our email screen, and we plan to copy the idea. On a small laptop, our tester had to scroll down to find Send.
The difference is the channel. FaveCard sends a Wallet notification, which is short (80 characters). StampMe sends app push or SMS, and connects to mailing tools. KANJIN sends a proper email that customers agreed to get.
Automatic messages
StampMe's "Lapsed Customers" is simple: pick how many days after the last stamp, write the message, switch it on. FaveCard automates birthdays. I did not see an option in either app to react to the weather. KANJIN can email regulars on its own when several rainy days are coming, because rain is when small shops go quiet.
Did the message work?
With no real customers in my trial accounts, I could not find a report or an empty placeholder in either app for how many people came back after a message. That is the question owners ask us most: "Did it work?" KANJIN puts the answer in one sentence: how many of the people you wrote to came back within a few days.
Money and suppliers
Neither of the other apps tries to help with sales, break-even or supplier bills. They are loyalty tools, and that is a fair choice. We added these because owners kept telling us their real worry is the end of the month.
What we are taking from them
- FaveCard's one-page message screen, with Send always in view and ready-made templates.
- Apple and Google Wallet passes, and separate share links for Instagram, Google and WhatsApp.
- StampMe's fun extras, like Scratch & Win, are a good reminder that loyalty can be playful.
What I would tell an owner choosing today
Pick the app that is fastest at the counter and easiest for customers to join. Everything else comes after. If your customers will not install an app, check how each product stamps them on day one. Try that job first, during the free trial, with a real person in front of you.
Each rival has its own page next to KANJIN, with sources: StampMe and FaveCard. All the comparisons are at /compare, and the plans are on the pricing page.
Roy Chen, Founder, KANJIN